Kathleen A.
12/6/2025
This is by far my favorite sandwich shop in the area. Order in person or online and the results are the same- yummy sandwiches! I love the Goomba as well as the Italian. Their pickles are always...
Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop - Castro Valley
$
Closed
(372)
Advertisement
Photos
20674 Rustic Dr
Castro Valley, CA 94546
Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop is a premium sandwich shop. Our shops offer hand sliced proprietary proteins and cheeses topped with sauces that are made daily. All sandwiches are served on our fresh baked rolls, including our famous Dutch Crunch roll. Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop offers best in class sandwiches including the famous Big Jake, Reuben, and of course The Mr. Pickle. Our twenty- six plus years of success is rooted in the simple formula of "Making the Guest Happy" by providing craveable sandwiches, exceptional guest service, and local community involvement.
Also at this address
Reviews
3.0372 reviews
Reina L.
12/14/2025
Mr. Pickles was open on Thanksgiving day when I was craving a sandwich!! I ordered The Hero on Dutch Crunch and the sandwich was exactly what I was wanting. Servers were super friendly, and the...
April P.
3/5/2025
A very good choice place for the hot pastrami Ruben I was seeking. Very good customer service Price per quantity to some can be on the expensive end but it's a hearty sandwich Ambiance: A...
Julia B.
2/8/2025
This place has tanked lately. I used to love their sandwiches but today's lunch was disgusting and truly inedible. My Mr Pickle Sammie was tiny amount of chicken it was so overcooked it was more...
Sarah V.
11/3/2025
We doordashed sandwiches from here and 2 out of 3 sandwiches were missing something or had very little fillings. blt with garlic spread didnt have the garlic spread. also ordered the listen linda,...
Owner verified
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement