Ken T.
12/3/2025
Great hole in the wall pizza spot downtown. The first time I had it, I ordered a Hawaiian and it was so good, but the next two times I got it it was really dry - so the quality seems inconsistent....
New York Pizza - San Mateo
$$
Closed
(346)
Advertisement
Photos
219 S B St
San Mateo, CA 94401
New York Pizza, established in the 1980s, has been a staple in California's pizza landscape, known for its dedication to quality and exceptional delivery service. With a commitment to using only the freshest ingredients, their secret recipe dough and sauces are made daily to ensure a satisfying experience for every customer.
In addition to their signature pizzas, New York Pizza offers a variety of catering options, including buffet-style salads, pastas, appetizers, and desserts, tailored to suit any event. This dedication to quality and service has earned them a loyal customer base, making them a favorite choice for pizza lovers in the Bay Area.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.5346 reviews
Jimmy C.
12/4/2025
The only reason this isn't a 1 star review is because last times I ordered, the pizza was decent. Large pesto chicken pizza. The good: Nothing. The bad: congealed cheese, forgot the sauce,...
Justin H.
9/17/2025
I used to think that this place was MrPizza Man, and I was confused and asked myself "when did Mr Pizza Man get so good?" The answer to that question is, "this isn't MrPizza Man, jackass." I'm...
Kristina K.
8/20/2025
I had never been to San Mateo, as I was walking down town I saw this spot & had to try it. It's a no frills kinda place. New York decor covers the wall & they have a TV going. It was super hot in...
Allen W.
5/15/2025
Hole in the wall vibes with indoor and outdoor seating. I appreciate that they sell by the slice, and at ~$8 dollars for the size of the slice, it seems like a good deal to me! The crust is thin...
See a problem?
You might also like
Advertisement