Chris H.
10/13/2025
Pizza was on point! Great beer selection for a warm coastal day. Ordered a pepperoni pizza and couldn't have been happier, sourdough crust adds a unique twist, and those crispy pepperoni hit...
Pie in the Sky
Open
(49)
Advertisement
Photos
156 Ocean Front Ln
Cayucos, CA 93430
Pie in the Sky, located in Cayucos, CA, is the brainchild of Jeremy and Ellen, a dynamic duo united by their passion for community and good food. With backgrounds in coffee and wine, they have transformed their culinary dreams into reality, blending their talents to create a welcoming space for locals and visitors alike.
Jeremy, a former non-profit developer, and Ellen, an experienced wine industry professional, have cultivated a creative and compassionate atmosphere at their pizzeria. Together, they continuously seek innovative ways to connect with their community while serving up delicious artisan pizzas that reflect their shared love for quality and creativity.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.049 reviewsMarcus T.
12/15/2025
I love to support local biz., but...... 3rd time I have ordered this pizza ( delivery). First 2 times were 'ok', the pepperoni pizza always came loaded with pepperoni, but what I noticed was the...
Michael H.
11/17/2025
Easiest five-star review ever. Outstanding SOURDOUGH crust. Got the pepperoni and added sausage and mushrooms. Other pizza was Less Haters More Taters. Both excellent. Ordered online. No...
Bryce S.
1/31/2025
NORTH COUNTY SAN LUIS OBISPO FINALLY HAS PIZZA! Located on Ocean Front Ave, down the street from the pier, is Pie in the Sky. This place has an order window and two tables. That's it! You, pizza...
John M.
5/24/2025
We're local and I've been wanting to try Pie in the Sky for a while...We finally did on a recent evening, and, while we liked it, it didn't blow us away so we'll continue our quest to find the...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement