Michelle A.
7/29/2025
Excellent key lime pie! I didn't know anything about this place but wanted to get a pie for a birthday celebration. My guests raved about this pie, it was thick, tangy, and had a delicious crust....
Buttermilk Bakery & Pie Shop
Closed
(7)
Advertisement
Photos
4212 S College Ave Unit 101
Fort Collins, CO 80525
Buttermilk Bakery & Pie Shop, located in Fort Collins, CO, offers a delightful selection of baked goods, including year-round pies, cakes, tortes, cheesecakes, and seasonal specialties. Nestled in the Hobby Lobby shopping center, the bakery is known for its delicious treats such as cocoa bombs, cake balls, and a variety of scones.
With a commitment to quality and flavor, Buttermilk Bakery & Pie Shop provides an array of options for special occasions, including Mother's Day and graduation celebrations. Customers can indulge in unique flavors and freshly made desserts that cater to all tastes and preferences.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.0(7)
Squid S.
12/21/2025
A little disappointed. Heard great things about this place, and ordered a Yule log and an espresso cheesecake. The Yule log turned out beautiful and delicious, the bakery was cute. The issue was...
Heather W.
11/13/2025
Cute local spot specializing in pies. I got a piece of buttermilk pie and OH MY. Absolutely delicious. The carrot cake cupcake was also incredible.. My daughter's boyfriend really liked the...
Kaily W.
5/9/2025
I used Buttermilk Bakery & Pie for my wedding cake in 2022, but more recently purchased one of their Mother's Day cookie bouquets (photo shown). This company is wonderful, the products are tasty...
Paula M.
1/9/2025
We called LATE at Christmas (12/23) hoping to order a buche de noel....and Buttermilk came through for us and we were able to pick it up on 12/24! Not only was it beautiful it was also incredibly...
See a problem?
You might also like
Advertisement