Martel W.
10/20/2024
First time trying Gaines Street Pies, it was a decent time of day on a Sunday for a Calzone and pizza. They came through with some good options. I went with a 10in pepperoni calzone, and 18in...
Gaines Street Pies
$
Closed
(64)
Advertisement
Photos
1184 Capital Cir NE Ste E
Tallahassee, FL 32301
Gaines Street Pies is the brainchild of two local visionaries who set out to craft the ultimate pizza experience in Tallahassee. By meticulously selecting top-quality ingredients and banishing frozen and processed items from their kitchen, they honed their recipes to perfection. Each item on their menu, from homemade meatballs to freshly whipped ranch dressing, showcases their dedication to culinary excellence.
Their innovative approach to pizza-making led to the birth of unique flavor combinations that captured the hearts of their patrons, prompting the rapid expansion of Gaines Street Pies. Within a short span, they opened additional locations, including one in Midtown and another in the Sixth District. Guests are invited to savor the distinctive taste of a Gaines Street Pie, a testament to the passion and artistry poured into every slice.
Generated from the website content
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
3.564 reviewsPaul E.
11/30/2025
I don't mind paying $3.50 to add onions to a large pizza, but what a JOKE on what they actually put on the pizza! I was very disappointed to see only a few pieces of onions. It is not like onions...
Lauren H.
5/22/2025
Best pizza place in Tallahassee! Pizza is fresh, handmade, and ingredients are delicious! Customer service is also amazing!
Robert S.
12/5/2025
Worst experience ordering from there. We have been ordering from Gaines Street Pies for years and had few problems. Lately it has gotten worse (long delays and cold items). However, the reason I'm...
Alexa R.
4/14/2024
Gaines St Pies is a Tallahassee staple. There is nothing like the White Album Pizza, perfectly complemented with truffle oil and tomatoes. If you are looking for something tasty and delicious,...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement