Taylor D.
9/8/2025
We wanted pizza tonight and these guys were closed, so we went to another local pizza joint and the crap experience made me want to leave a five star review for Italy Pizzaria, who we cheated on...
Italy Pizzeria College Park
Open
(22)
Advertisement
Photos
2124 Edgewater Dr
Orlando, FL 32804
Eataly Pizzeria College Park is a cozy eatery in Orlando, FL that specializes in serving authentic Italian-style pizzas.
With a focus on quality ingredients and traditional recipes, this pizzeria offers a casual dining experience for those seeking a taste of Italy.
Generated from their business information
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
4.522 reviews
Danielle Elaine M.
4/26/2025
Pizza was pretty good, nice thing crispy crust and not too oily. Other dishes - Alfredo and Philly- fell short. Too oily and could have used more flavor. Service was slow and missed a few items,...
Craig L.
12/13/2024
I am an unashamed pizza lover. Always on the prowl for the best pizza around. Wow!! This is the real deal. This pizza lover from NJ just found the perfect slice right here in Orlando. I...
Michael W.
11/9/2024
Visit number 2 was great. I was quickly greeted and seated. They have seating both inside and out so I chose outside. 10" Primavera Bianca was delicious. Fresh ingredients and came out nice and hot.
Dave K.
5/8/2025
I am total pizza snob. I prefer a well done thin style pizza with ZERO flop crust (like Dave Portnoy). Italy Pizzeria College Park is the best pizza in Orlando. Dave Portnoy would give them 8.3...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement