J. J. Gandy's Pies, Inc

Permanently closed
tripadvisor logo

(176)

Call
Website

Advertisement

Photos

3725 Alt 19
Palm Harbor, FL 34683
J.J. Gandy's Pies opened for business in October of 1982. Our name comes from "J" for Jeff ( son ), "J" for Jodi ( daughter ), "G" for Gay ( Mom ), "Andy" for Andy ( he got his entire name in there...he is Dad! ) and "S" for our last name, Schmidt. Originally located in Alderman Plaza from 1982 until 1987, we outgrew our space there and relocated to our present location at 3725 Alt. 19 ( Palm Harbor Blvd ). Over the years, we have done very little advertising. You, the customer, are our best advertisement. Thank you for spreading our "sweet news". We also sell to over 100 restaurants in the Tampa Bay area. Our specialty is pies. Key Lime pie is our best seller by far ; all of our customers say it's the best Key Lime pie they have ever had. Many of our pies have been hand-carried across the country and around the world to share with distant family and friends. During the Thanksgiving and Christmas holidays, our famous Pumpkin Chiffon pie takes over as the best seller. All of our pies are guaranteed to satisfy your taste buds. We make all of our fillings from scratch. Taste the difference! Free samples are always available. If you just stroll into our shop we have several pies on hand and some that are made fresh to order while you wait. Fruit pies ( two-crusted baked pies ) should be ordered a day in advance. ( we do bake a few each day but would prefer that you get yours hot from the oven ). During the holidays we highly recommend that you order all of your pies as early as possible. Thanksgiving is our busiest holiday, with as many as 3000 pies being made. We are also known for our delicious wedding cakes and can be designed for any occasion. We make our own butter cream and fudge icings.

Reviews

tripadvisor logo
5.0176 reviews
Photo of jaybeeFL
Can't Wait To Go Back
3/16/2024

Friends told us about Gandy's expounding on how great the key lime pie was!!! Had to give it a try s...

Photo of RICHARDT699
Fantastic Key Lime Pie!
3/7/2024

We made a 3 hour roundtrip to J.J.Gandy's to buy two Key Lime Pies. We always get down there at lea...

Photo of brianpZ7183NB
A must see and experience bakery.
6/6/2023

Yum. Bakeries do not get any better than JJ Gandy. Best key lime pie ever. Repeat customer here. Lov...

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesFloridaPalm HarborJ. J. Gandy's Pies, Inc

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.

Advertisement