Mattheessen's

$
Open
yelp logo

(39)

Call
Website

Advertisement

Photos

614 Greene St
Key West, FL 33040
This is a satellite store to our main store on Duval Street. Serving the same homemade ice cream , cookies and key lime pie.A little quieter off the beaten path. Quaint room. A must stop in to cool off and refresh with some goodies.

Reviews

yelp logo
4.539 reviews
Photo of Josh T.
Josh T.
11/9/2025

Great place to stop in for a coffee or latte, some fresh baked goods, or an ice cream. We stopped by various times for all the above on our daily walks. The staff was always welcoming.

Photo of Garrett Z.
Garrett Z.
11/23/2025

You had me at giant cookies and ice cream. Fun, little shop to pop into and get a sugar rush. We tried the giant chocolate chip cookie and a couple scoops of ice cream. The giant cookie was gooey...

Photo of April W.
April W.
7/5/2024

While stopped at port on a cruise we decided to visit Mattheessen's. The giant cookies looked amazinggg and we just had to give them a try!! The place is super cool, with ice cream and the bakery...

Photo of Craig W.
Craig W.
4/2/2024

This shop has very nice ice cream and cookies as big as hubcaps. I'm only exaggerating a little. The cookies are ridiculously big and looked amazing. However, we only tried the ice cream. The...

Photo of Shelly L.
Shelly L.
3/7/2024

We had ice cream and got a giant, and I mean giant, cookie to go. Ice cream was creamy and had great flavor, portions are decent...at $7 a scoop you want a generous scoop. Giant cookie was good...

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesFloridaKey WestMattheessen's

Partial Data by Foursquare.

Advertisement