Jenifer M.
11/3/2025
OMG! The best of the best oysters in the Keys! We got the same bartender 2 years in a row and she knows exactly what we like... 1/2 shells and a steamed platter mixed. You have to get the...
Pepe's Cafe
$$
Open
(1,053)
Advertisement
Photos
806 Caroline St
Key West, FL 33040
OLDEST EATING HOUSE IN THE KEYS Pepe's Cafe is the oldest eatery in the Florida Keys, and 2nd Oldest in the State of Florida. Harry Truman was a regular, along with many others whose photos are hanging on our walls. Our juices are fresh-squeezed and our oysters are shucked to order. Breads are fresh-made daily, and the only freezer in the House is for the ice cream. We make our own salad dressings as well as our Proprietary Hot Sauces. Happy Hour 4-6pm
Also at this address
Reviews
4.01,053 reviews
Sharron B.
9/12/2025
The steak melts in ur mouth/all the sides were amazing & prepared perfectly/ The atmosphere inside the restaurant is cozy and welcoming with wooden benches and creaky wooden floors We were served...
Adrian F.
8/23/2025
Pepe's Café in Key West is the kind of joint that laughs in the face of Yelp trends and cocktail menus with smoke machines. Founded in 1909, it's the oldest restaurant in town, and it wears its...
Maria R.
12/4/2025
This is an amazing place with so much history. Per the locals this has been here since the early 1900s. If you are looking for good food and locals recommendations this is the place to go. Service...
Mike M.
10/8/2025
Amazing place!! Must stop every time we're in Kw. Service is phenomenal and their oysters are off the charts!!
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement