American Pie Pizzeria

being italian, and born/raised in NY.. and having an Epic Italian Grandmother who made the worlds best pizzas.. and other Italian owned/operated pizzerias in NY i grew up enjoying, I am "picky"...

I keep missing the buffet. I think I forget it's a buffet at a certain time. But I have been here a few times. I once did a takeout order of wings. Side note: The wings are better than any other...

Terrible Pizza, the dough is all wrong and tastes bland. The sauce is okay, but the cheese ratio is way off. Little kids running the place, always on their phones. Save your money!

We had the most amazing pizza yesterday. We picked it up and brought it home and ate every morsel! Literally, the BEST pizza I can remember ever eating!

I guess taste really does differ. Someone else, who gave 5 stars, said they have an Italian grandma and are very picky about their pizza. I'm the same - for pizza and Italian food. I did not try...