Billie M.
6/14/2025
So cute and nostalgic! it's inviting and you feel like the staff knows their regulars. They are happy to allow me to try different flavors and everything tasted so good that it was hard to decide....
Hartigan's Ice Cream Shoppe
$
Closed
(83)
Advertisement
Photos
2909 Central St
Evanston, IL 60201
Hartigan's Ice Cream Shoppe, celebrating 44 years on Central Street in Evanston, IL, is renowned for its exceptional and flavorful ice cream desserts, as well as custom ice cream cakes. Proudly recognized as a Legacy Business, Hartigan's creates a welcoming atmosphere for families and friends, offering special events like live music nights.
In addition to their diverse menu, which features over 165 Kosher-certified products from Cedar Crest Ice Cream, Hartigan's also engages with the community through birthday parties and educational programs for kids. The shop has a notable connection to the film industry, having been featured in the movie "A Light Beneath Their Feet," further adding to its unique charm and local appeal.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.083 reviewsDarren B.
9/29/2025
Coconut Joy.... Mmmm. Best, freshest ice cream around. Why should I have to type more? Just get Coconut Joy.
Sarah A.
7/3/2024
Great selection of ice cream at this old-timey place. I tried the seasonal peach flavor which tasted fresh and homemade. The service is pretty good! Just wish there was more seating room.
Tikku G.
11/1/2023
Stopped by for some quick dessert, got a scoop of their butter pecan. Creamy and yummy, a bit pricy for what you get but nevertheless a solid scoop of ice cream!
Latoya W.
7/7/2024
Hartigan's is an old school creamery. Lots of flavors, and other treats such as floats, bakery treats and more. Great for families and friends. Go Cool off and grab a scoop!
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Advertisement