Ronele Y.
11/20/2025
Best food ever but so disappointed that they got rid of charred octopus. Please bring it back!!!! From your loyal, disappointed patron .
Brooklyn and The Butcher
$$$
Closed
(301)
Advertisement
Photos
148 E Market St
New Albany, IN 47150
For three years, Brooklyn and the Butcher has pushed the envelop, embraced the new, and changed what it means to be a steakhouse. For us, modern is more than just a tagline; it’s a personal challenge to pursue greatness in every aspect of fine hospitality. Join us at Brooklyn and the Butcher, where small plates and BIG STEAKS are waiting.
Also at this address
Reviews
4.0301 reviews
Chelsea A.
10/17/2025
Brooklyn & Butcher was my go to before Pandemic. Just absolutely decadent. Perfectly cooked steak, sauces seasoned so well, the smoked tomatoes OMG, generous portions. Most satisfied meal I've had...
Jordan S.
1/7/2025
This is a place I have overlooked for a while, and wow I am glad I had a chance to try. There is a good chance this might be the best dining experience in Clark-Floyd county, at least it's the...
Heather O.
9/14/2025
Waitress is great, only reason for the 1 star, Just not sure how at 5pm on a Sunday with 3 tables in the restaurant you are out of 2 main items Spring Mountain Chicken and Corn tortellini. Bread...
Kimiko D.
5/12/2025
Visiting from out of town and found this gem. Our server, Anna, was so warm and welcoming- walked us through the somewhat "confusing" menu (reason we deducted one star). We wanted a Rib-eye but...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement