Lina C.
7/3/2025
Updating my review as I visited a few weeks ago and was very happy with my visit! They completely renovated their store and it looks wonderful. They also updated their menu to specify prices for...
Butterfingers
$$
Open
(64)
Advertisement
Photos
2552 45th St
Highland, IN 46322
Butterfingers is a beloved dessert and delicatessen shop that has been a fixture in the Highland and Munster area for over 30 years, dedicated to bringing joy to the community through their meticulously crafted creations. Their focus on quality ensures that every dish and dessert is a delightful experience for patrons.
What sets Butterfingers apart is their nurturing work environment, where every team member is valued and treated like family, fostering a collaborative spirit that drives continual innovation. This happy and supportive atmosphere enables the team to make a positive impact in the community, one sweet creation at a time.
Generated from the website
Reviews
3.564 reviews
Becky G.
12/4/2025
I am really disappointed at the changes in the baked goods. I went to pick up 2 cakes I had called to reserve. When I got there, 2 days before Thanksgiving, I discovered that they were only single...
Blake B.
5/23/2025
The spicy seafood pasta salad is to die for! The cupcakes are always moist and the croissants are fresh and crisp with a soft center.
Ryan Y.
1/11/2025
The iced brownie gets 5 big booms! BOOM BOOOM BOOM BOOM BOOM' Would totally recommend butterfingers, birthday cake is defaulted to the banana cake from here !
Andrew M.
4/22/2025
Attitude over no tip? $28 on food to feed 2 people, and mad over a tip? I didnt even eat in lol. Was in and out in 5 minutes
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement