Rich J.
7/17/2025
I am a pizza lover. If I could have it every meal I would. Goodfellas has the best traditional , New York style I guess, style pizza. It is brick oven pizza but not like the modern frou frou...
GOODFELLA'S Brick Oven Pizza & Pasta Restaurant
$$
Closed
(119)
Advertisement
Photos
9641 Olio Rd
Mccordsville, IN 46055
At Goodfella's, we pride ourselves on preparing a delicious meal for every customer, every time. Our ingredients are fresh, and our staff is friendly and courteous. For your convenience, we offer dine-in, pickup and delivery service.
Also at this address
Reviews
3.5119 reviewsJohn W.
12/5/2025
I just ordered $60 large take out Margarita pizza with prosciutto and jalapeños. Salad and breadsticks amounted to a whopping $80 Uber Eats evening. Opened the pizza, dug into it and could only...
Mark E.
1/28/2025
Half off wine bottles on Tuesday. Great selection of entrees and brick oven pizzas. Casual atmosphere. Would be great place to hang out after work. Great lunch menu options with very...
Kyle A.
3/29/2025
Walked out after sitting and waiting for service a long time. On the way out, the host didn't even care that we had no service. Based on some of the reviews at this place, I don't think the food...
Corey S.
7/13/2025
Probably the worst positive review, but it was Okay. Standard, run of the mill pizza. I wouldn't go out of my way to get it again but it's better than the pizza chains
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Advertisement