Katherine A.
7/29/2025
I took my granddaughter to My Sugar Pie for an end of summer, afternoon treat. My Sugar Pie has become an institution in downtown Zionsville, serving the freshest of homemade pies. You can order...
My Sugar Pie
$$
Closed
(130)
Advertisement
Photos
40 E Pine St
Zionsville, IN 46077
My Sugar Pie in Zionsville, IN is a renowned pie shop that offers a delectable selection of gourmet homemade pies. With a menu featuring a variety of flavors, including the classic rhubarb and strawberry combination, their pies are sure to satisfy any sweet tooth.
Whether you choose to visit their charming pie shop or have their delicious pies shipped to your doorstep, My Sugar Pie is dedicated to providing a delightful pie experience. Don't miss out on their special offers, such as the Sweet 16th Birthday Slice Special, where you can enjoy three slices for just $16.
Generated from the website
Reviews
4.5130 reviewsL T.
12/3/2025
Pie was a gift at Thanksgiving holiday. I usually make my own pies, but the thought was nice. The Dutch Apple was just ok. Waaaay too much sugar in the crust: I like to taste the fruit....
Phil B.
9/7/2025
Lots and lots of pie out on display. I got one slice of sugar cream and it was really good. What sugar cream should taste like. My husband does not like pie crust so unfortunately they didn't have...
Hndiana R.
11/28/2025
Delicious!! Pies are wonderful! Large variety to choose from to satisfy all tastes! My favorite is the cherry.
Leigh F.
3/15/2025
We went to tea at My Sugar Pie today and it was such a delight! Delightful food options from savory to sweet. Lots of selections and such delightful service! The location's natural coziness lended...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement