Penn Station East Coast Subs

$$
Closed
yelp logo

(42)

Call
Website

Advertisement

Photos

9785 E 116th St
Fishers, IN 46037
Our menu features an array of mouth watering Grilled Penn Station submarine sandwiches, fresh-cut fries and hand-squeezed lemonade. All sandwiches are prepared fresh in full view of the customer using delicious hearth-baked bread, USDA Choice Steak and the finest meats, cheeses and vegetables. The potatoes are hand selected, fresh-cut and flash-fried in cholesterol-free peanut oil. The lemonade is made from scratch every day using hand-squeezed lemons.

Also at this address

Reviews

yelp logo
3.042 reviews
Nicole P.
11/20/2025

They make the best subs! There is always ample meat, unlike most other sub places. It's not bc it's Penn Station. It's the location. I've to other locs that don't stack up! Definitely my favorite...

Photo of Sheree W.
Sheree W.
8/17/2024

Came here because I had a coupon 2 small subs, 2 small fries and 2 small drinks for 22 dollars. Had to wait a few minutes to for someone to take my order, even though nobody was in front of us,...

Chandler W.
9/30/2025

Never have any problems with this place. The food is always spot on. The service is always great

Zach T.
2/11/2025

The food was great. service was fast and friendly, Nick was an amazing server. His amazing attitude made my day

Photo of Jess M.
Jess M.
11/30/2023

Decent sandwiches and delicious fries. Not sure I'd call this a favorite, but it definitely hit the spot. Make sure to load up on the condiments if you get the multigrain - mine was pretty dry.

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesIndianaFishersPenn Station East Coast Subs

Advertisement