Danielle P.
7/16/2025
These sandwiches were filling and tasty. We had the classic for breakfast We added some spinach and turkey sausage it was yummy. For lunch we had the skinny pig and skinny bird and took them to...
Portly Pilgrim
$
Closed
(28)
Advertisement
Photos
170 Water St
Plymouth, MA 02360
The Portly Pilgrim is a newly established sandwich shop located in the historic town of Plymouth, Massachusetts. Offering a delectable menu of hand-carved turkey, slow-braised corned beef, smoked beef brisket, fresh lobster, and more, this eatery is a haven for those seeking a satisfying meal.
With their signature sandwich, The Portly Pilgrim, featuring a double-decker day-after-Thanksgiving feast, complete with hand-carved turkey breast, Nana's stuffing, cranberry bread, and a slice of gravy-bread, this sandwich shop is sure to leave patrons stuffed and satisfied.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.528 reviews
Janet D.
10/12/2025
A no frills counter service excellent sandwich shop. We didn't have a long wait because there wasn't anyone ahead of us. Anyone after us had to wait in line outside the shop. Owner runs a one-man...
Frederick C.
10/11/2025
Visiting Plymouth and found this cozy little place with a great sounding menu. Definitely a grab and go place, just enough room to order and move aside so the next person behind you can order. I...
Jean M.
8/26/2025
So i wanted to love this place so many options they all sounded good. Until I sat there and watched the sandwich get made. The amount of butter put on that sandwich could give anyone a heart...
Patrick G.
12/8/2023
After first checking out The Portly Pilgrim on a solo visit back in October I ventured back today with orders for the whole family. Today we got the Burial Hill (without bacon), the Patuxet...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement