Tony C.
7/18/2025
First time here. All I can say is WOW. Four of us came in for pizza. Started with onion rings, they were terrific. We got the Brooklyn square and a medium round pie with meatballs. Outstanding...
Classico Tomato Pies
$
Closed
(136)
Advertisement
Photos
358 Princeton Hightstown Rd
Princeton Junction, NJ 08550
Classico Tomato Pies, located in West Windsor Township, NJ, is a renowned restaurant that specializes in serving delicious tomato pies made with fresh ingredients. With a commitment to providing a real home-cooked meal experience, every item on their menu is made to order. Whether you choose to dine in or order takeout, Classico Tomato Pies guarantees a satisfying and flavorful dining experience that will leave you wanting more. Owned by Steve Cabrera, Linda Pittari, and James Pittari, Classico Tomato Pies prides itself on offering a unique twist to traditional pizza pies. With their signature tomato pies, the cheese is placed directly on the crust before the crushed tomatoes, seasonings, and oil are added. This distinctive approach sets them apart from other pizza establishments and has earned them a reputation as one of Mercer's best tomato pie restaurants.
Generated from the website
Reviews
4.0136 reviews
Catelyn H.
9/25/2025
After my OrangeTheory workout I was craving pizza and this place happened to be in the same parking lot. The staff upon entering were friendly and got me seated right away! I was going for...
Eatwell F.
9/8/2025
Lady Eatwell and I joined two friends at Classico last Friday, 9/5/2025. It was our first time there. My friends highly recommended it, and said they go regularly. At 6:00 the dining room was...
Alex H.
12/25/2024
Classico Tomato Pies in West Windsor is a casual Italian pizza parlor with solid tomato pies along with pasta and other Italian dishes. We had the pasta allá Classico (hot sausage and broccoli...
Jerry F.
5/31/2025
Just wanted to update as Steve has gone from standard Jedi to the Jedi Council. Congrats on your promotion, Steve. Best tomato pie in the area and it's not close. It gets better and better every time.
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Advertisement