Dolly C.
10/19/2025
- Open, spacious pizzeria with plenty of seating for dine-in; clean and comfortable environment - Steady flow of customers on a Saturday evening during dinner - Service was quick and friendly -...
Mario's Pizza
$
Open
(116)
Advertisement
Photos
132 W Pleasant Ave
Maywood, NJ 07607
Mario's Pizzeria in Maywood, New Jersey, is a great neighborhood pizzeria and restaurant. It serves Italian food-classic southern Italian dishes, pizzas, salads and much more. Try our Grandma's slice, it will liven up your day. The slice is rectangular like a Sicilian, but half as thick with fresh mozzarella topped with crushed tomatoes, fresh basil, pecorino romano cheese , oregano and a touch of olive oil
Also at this address
Reviews
3.0(116)
Chris E.
10/19/2025
THE GOOD ---------------- + Wide variety of gourmet pizzas to choose from - White, Margherita, Buffalo Chicken, Hawaiian, Meat Lovers, Sicilian, etc. + LOTs of menu items besides pizza - Meat...
sarah m.
1/14/2026
Absolutely no reason to have this anything lower than a 4.5-5 star rating. Service is nice and ok. But the show is the pizza and the star is their red sauce. The Margherita is immaculate amongst...
Chris A.
3/18/2025
3rd review in 16 years.... New Owners Prices continue to climb and yes, it's happening everywhere but here the food is getting worse. Ordered a few cold hero sandwiches. The bread was terrible....
Vincent M.
11/23/2025
My wife and I have been eating Mario's pizza and subs for over 10 years and for the most part have been extremely satisfied with it all. We ordered a Pizza half meatball and onion, the other half...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement