Mark C.
10/29/2025
Love going to the new Monmouth diner baking incredible hamburgers cheeseburgers open face sandwiches soups salads and most of all their desserts are incredible.
New Monmouth Diner
$
Closed
(219)
Advertisement
Photos
1887 State Route 35
Middletown, NJ 07748
New Monmouth Diner, located in Middletown, NJ, has earned the title of Best Diner for seven consecutive years, offering a diverse menu that provides restaurant-quality food at diner prices. The establishment is known for its inviting atmosphere and a dedication to satisfying its patrons with delicious meals served in a classic diner style.
Conveniently situated on Route 35, New Monmouth Diner also offers the option to order online and through popular delivery services like DoorDash, making it accessible for those seeking a quick and tasty dining experience. With its longstanding reputation and commitment to quality, this diner stands out as a local favorite.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.5(219)
Candice K.
12/24/2025
The ambiance is often crowded, but not too noisy. The diner is well managed. Waitstaff experience widely varies from competent to inexperienced. What's disturbing is when waitstaff projects an...
Stephy S.
11/7/2025
My 2 star review being changed to 3 star. Good is good but not amazing. Quick service but you don't feel pressured to leave.
James F.
8/17/2025
First New Jersey diner we have been to in a very long time! This made me miss New Jersey more than ever. We had a fantastic meal. I had my favorite New Jersey diner food, which was a western...
Steve S.
12/12/2024
This is an amazing diner. I have come here a few times now, and it never fails. The food is always delicious. My favorite item is the Boom Boom Burger. It's just so juicy and flavorful. The...
See a problem?
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement