David Y.
7/30/2025
I was around the area and was in the mood for a quick slice. Found this place via Google and decided to give this place a shot since it was very close by. This review is based on their special....
Salvatore's Pizzeria
Closed
(10)
Advertisement
Photos
1286 RT-35
Middletown, NJ 07748
Salvatore's Pizzeria in Middletown NJ offers a delightful selection of authentic Italian pizzas made with fresh ingredients and traditional recipes. Known for its cozy atmosphere and friendly service this eatery is a favorite among locals seeking a quick bite or a family meal. Whether you prefer classic Margherita or loaded specialty pies Salvatore's ensures a satisfying dining experience for everyone.
Generated from this place's information
Reviews
4.510 reviewsPete P.
12/27/2025
Fantastic pizza and it's always great to see Sal and have good conversation over great pizza.
R D.
11/12/2025
Same excellent pizza as when he was "Villa at Shop Rite", now located on the other side of Route 35. No skimping on ingredients. And his prices are lower than others too.
Jordan W.
11/16/2025
My order experience was disappointing. The staff were disorganized, customer service was poor, and the food preparation could have been cleaner. I hope they improve these areas.
Gary V.
5/28/2025
Great pizza made by an even better man Sal is a great guy making delicious pizza in a great little pizza shop deserves more customers
See a problem?
You might also like
Advertisement