Sarah M.
10/3/2022
I wish I could express how much I genuinely enjoyed this place and the experience. You order as soon as you walk in and the hostess realized we weren't regulars and took a few extra minutes to...
Sammy's Ye Old Cider Mill
$$$
Closed
(196)
Advertisement
Photos
353 Mendham Rd W
Mendham, NJ 07945
Sammy's Ye Old Cider Mill in Mendham, NJ, is a steakhouse located in a former speakeasy. The restaurant specializes in dry-aged, hand-cut steaks and features a basement bar serving classic cocktails. This family business has been operating for three generations, offering a unique dining experience.
The menu includes a variety of dishes, such as shrimp scampi, penne vodka, and apple crisp, alongside prime cuts of meat. With a focus on quality ingredients and a quaint atmosphere, Sammy's combines tradition and culinary excellence in a historic setting.
Generated from the website
Reviews
3.0(196)
B T.
12/6/2025
Thank God their selling. This place is the worst. Tacky, tacky tacky. The steak was better at the now defunct Sizzlers; sadly, so is the ambience. When you walk in they take your order...
Steve B.
1/11/2026
Overpriced overrated garbage. Locals eat this place up and I have no idea why. I could cook a better steak on a hot plate at home. Hopefully the new owners will get rid of the sewage smell too
Claudia K.
6/30/2025
Here is the pithy essence of what will be a detailed review: outrageous owner arrogance ruined what would have been a wonderful meal (and five-star review) at a restaurant my family has been...
Joe G.
12/15/2025
Very tired and living on it's past reputation. The basement is reminiscent of an old fraternity bar basement in 1970 - although dirtier. Salad is less than one would expect in Friendly's. The...
See a problem?
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement