Dale K.
12/7/2025
We drove past this place thousands of times, but somehow never tried it. Until recently. So glad we did & wish we had sooner! Thumbs up all around--delicious food, great service, nice roomy room....
Stefano's Restaurant
$$
Closed
(93)
Advertisement
Photos
565 Nj-23
Pompton Plains, NJ 07444
Stefano's Ristorante in Pompton Plains, NJ is a family-owned Italian restaurant that has been serving authentic Italian cuisine for over 45 years. With a menu filled with delicious homemade pasta dishes, seafood, and specialties, this popular eatery offers a romantic ambiance in its intimate dining room, as well as al fresco dining options.
Known for their fresh homemade pastas, Stefano's is a hidden gem located on Route 23 South. The restaurant's Tuscan decor and opera music create a charming atmosphere, perfect for a quick lunch or a relaxing dinner. Whether you're a regular customer or a first-time visitor, Stefano's is sure to impress with their flavorful dishes and warm hospitality.
Generated from the website
Reviews
3.093 reviews
Rick J.
3/22/2025
Arrogant and utterly rude owner/staff and overpriced mediocre small portions. Went with a large party and was severely disappointed with the food and nasty owner who thinks it's appropriate to go...
Petre D.
5/28/2025
I can only imagine that some reviews are made up. However, most negative reviews are not about the food per se, but about the service. .....Negative reviews appear abundant throughout the...
Yo M.
5/18/2025
Came for a party. Food was served family style and super good! Service was amazing too.
Richard M.
7/9/2025
$39 for Lasagna is ridiculous !!!!!! How can you justify that? I talked to the manager or owner. He told me the sauce was made in house and no one ever complained about the price!! I don't believe it!
Owner verified
See a problem?
You might also like
Advertisement