Warren B.
1/4/2026
I'll drive down from Mendham for their bagels. They're that good. Hot from the oven. Bring cash, they don't take credit or debit cards. The salt bagels are sublime. An everything bagel charms....
The Hot Bagel Bakery
$
Closed
(102)
Advertisement
Photos
67 Monmouth Rd Ste 2
Oakhurst, NJ 07755
The Hot Bagel Bakery, located in Oakhurst, NJ, has been delighting customers since 1979. Brothers Dan and John Grimes oversee the operations, ensuring that each bagel meets the high standards set by the Jersey Shore Orthodox Rabbinate. Using only the finest ingredients, the bakery prides itself on hand-rolling each bagel to achieve the perfect texture and taste.
Utilizing an old-fashioned barrel mixer, the dough is expertly crafted to provide the ideal bagel crunch. Boiled and baked in a revolving oven, every bagel from The Hot Bagel Bakery is a labor of love. With a commitment to quality and flavor, the bakery aims to deliver the best-tasting bagels you'll ever experience.
Generated from the website content
Also at this address
Reviews
4.5(102)
Marc K.
11/11/2024
Hands down the best bagels in the area. Have tried many other places before giving this place the "go to" #1 spot. Granted one other place is decent if you want to make sandwiches maybe, but Hot...
Beachy K.
6/19/2025
The BEST bagels in NJ. Maybe even NY. I moved out west 13 years ago and I can't get anything like these there. When I come back to visit I pig out on these, and I'm gluten free. It's worth it.
Jude P.
11/25/2025
Great place, great bagels good food. I liked it when it was Belmar Bagels, but my one complaint is the blonde with no expression. Her skills on the phone are horrible, she answers the phone all...
Neil G.
6/14/2025
These bagels are some of the best anywhere. Always fresh and made throughout the day. You can get smoked salmon, cream cheese and butter too.
See a problem?
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.
Advertisement