Food

McCarty's Cafe

Closed

(34)

Call

Website

Photos

500 W 2nd St

Portales, NM 88130

+1 (575) 359-2023

https://www.mccartyscafe.com

McCarty's Cafe is a popular eatery located in the heart of Portales, New Mexico, offering a diverse menu of delicious dishes. With their convenient online ordering system, customers can easily enjoy their flavorful meals with just a few clicks.

Known for their mouthwatering cuisine, McCarty's Cafe is a go-to destination for locals and visitors alike. Whether you're craving breakfast, lunch, or dinner, their extensive menu has something to satisfy every palate.

Generated from the website

Reviews

4.034 reviews

Otto C.

7/7/2015

I was in Portales on business from New York State. All these good ratings are right on. Steak fingers! Have never seen this and loved it. Good fries, very good cole slaw and roll. Gravy to die...

Read more on Yelp

Tom G.

11/23/2025

I ordered the steak strips after finding out that no one who worked there had ever tried the fish. One of the worst things I have ever ordered. This shop had a very large menu with nothing made...

Read more on Yelp

James S.

5/26/2025

Great place for steak or chicken fingers and don't miss out on the fried green chili strips, lots more on the menu

Read more on Yelp

Sharon G.

9/18/2023

If I could give zero stars, I would! The service was ABSOLUTELY HORRIBLE. The food is not much better. After we ate, I ordered two pieces of Boston Cream Pie, which was frozen!!! We used to...

Read more on Yelp

Phyllis D.

8/27/2024

Food is generally very good but do not use the online application. I was mistaken that it was open on Saturdays. I now know that McCarty's Closes at 2 on Saturday. Thinking it was open I...

Read more on Yelp

Own this business?

See a problem?

Bridal shops, Hobby and craft supplies, Commercial and industrial building operation

The Happy Place

The Happy Place on the square is a proud, certified #NewMexicoTrue supplier. With a variety of of authentic New Mexican gifts, we make it our mission to share our #NewMexicoTrue spirit with all! If you're looking for something to do, The Happy Place has plenty of arcade games to entertain customers of all ages. Plus, we have a candy store! Come see us for a new spin on #NewMexicoTrue!