Colette G.
7/28/2025
5 star bagels with 3 star service. NOBODY makes bagels as big & fluffy as Bagel Lady. We are hooked, for over 20 years. THIS is our bagel place. But JUST bagels is all we patronize them for. We...
Bagel Lady Cafe
$
Closed
(63)
Advertisement
Photos
99 Route 25A
Shoreham, NY 11786
Bagel Lady Cafe offers a variety of bagels and café-style food. The establishment aims to provide a casual dining experience for customers looking to enjoy their meals at their own pace.
The café has received mixed feedback regarding service speed and staff interaction. Customers have reported varying experiences, with some praising the food while others expressed dissatisfaction with service efficiency.
Generated from the web
Also at this address
Reviews
2.563 reviewsDan F.
12/7/2025
Came in with my friends and the workers were super friendly and caring and the food was amazing. Best Bacon egg and cheese I've ever had and don't even get me started on the coffee, incredible.
Jake F.
12/7/2025
Food is top tier and that ratio on the bacon egg cheese is immaculate. Staff is amazing, great local joint.
Antonio C.
12/7/2025
Incredible food and even better service! My first time ever being to Long Island and this was the first bagel spot I tried. Came back the very next day for more.
Joseph M.
4/17/2025
I grew up in Shoreham, worked for a decade at the Rocky Point Italian Bakery making Italian bread and I can honestly say these bagels are second to none, especially in the TOB. The owner has grown...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Advertisement