Elizabeth H.
6/24/2025
Another great visit! Affordable, fresh, clean and quick! What more can you ask for from a pizza place.
Baxter Street Pizza
$
Closed
(30)
Advertisement
Photos
83 Baxter St
New York, NY 10013
The Pie Guy, located at 83 Baxter Street in New York, NY, is a beloved pizzeria known for its classic New York-style pizzas made with whole milk mozzarella and fresh tomato-basil sauce. Offering a diverse menu that includes unique options like the Signature Spicy Rigatoni Pizza and numerous toppings, this establishment has gained popularity among both locals and visitors.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
4.530 reviews
Jeff M.
9/24/2025
The Pie Guy Pizza 83 Baxter St. New York, NY 10013 Pepperoni Slice This slice was topped with an abundant supply of pepperoni cups; there was pepperoni in every bite. It had a flop, but was...
Irene S.
5/24/2025
If you're craving pizza, this place will do the trick. Nice thin slice with a perfect crust. Got the Margherita and a sausage... all fairly quickly as they had it in display and just had to warm...
Jillian B.
3/14/2025
I've walked by The Pie Guy dozens of times but never had the opportunity to try it until this evening. Because it's Pi day, I figured I might as well enjoy a slice of pizza (or two!). I opted for...
Tom F.
11/6/2024
Walked in & ordered a margarita pie for take out. Pie Guy guy says "gimme 15 minutes". No problemo. In the meantime I observe the slice window & everything looks copacetic (except the fried...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement