Civitello's Italian Pastry Shoppe

Great pastry, service and atmosphere. The tomato pie needs work. The sauce drags this iconic staple down. The topping is bland in the way it was not originally. I've been making pizza and tomato...

Been going to Civitello's since the early 70's and am not going to stop now! The new owner Mark is working hard to keep the Civitello's legacy alive. Since it reopened I've been going weekly on...

Civitello's reopened under its new owner Mark Novak on July 31, 2025 after renovations which included new plumbing and wiring. The new owner promised to keep the shop looking the same, and it...

Walked over here on my lunch break to try. Large cases of freshly cooked bread, cookies and cupcakes. Prices were reasonable, $6 each cupcake. Delicious I might add, perfectly cooked. It was hard...

So happy Civitello's finally reopened. However, after waiting in line for 25 minutes , (at 12:30 in the afternoon) staff announced that they were no longer taking any orders. The people sitting...