V. J.
12/8/2024
I randomly stopped here for some ice cream with my daughter. We had the pleasure of having Mike W wait on us. He was very personable, and patient. He's also very knowledgeable about flavor...
Cold Stone Creamery
Closed
(9)
Advertisement
Photos
25 Hicksville Rd
Massapequa, NY 11758
Your local Cold Stone Creamery in Massapequa, NY is the ultimate ice cream shop offering Create Your Own Creations™ mixed on a granite slab, custom ice cream cakes for any occasion, and rich, creamy milkshakes. Indulge in endless flavors, mix-ins, and sweet treats made fresh just for you. Try our two new holiday flavors: Frosted Gingerbread ice cream and Marshmallow Moose Tracks® Fudge. Celebrate the season with two NEW holiday cakes: Iced and Spiced made with layers of moist Yellow Cake, Frosted Gingerbread Ice Cream, Ginger Snaps & Holiday Sprinkles wrapped in fluffy White Frosting and Layer on the Moose Tracks® Fudge Cake, made with layers of moist Devil's Food Cake & Marshmallow Ice Cream made with Moose Tracks® Fudge wrapped in fluffy White Frosting!
Also at this address
Reviews
2.09 reviews
Nick V.
11/17/2025
I ordered 4 cups online for pick up. All 4 were made wrong. I tried calling multiple times and they refused to answer the phone. The peanut butter cup was made with vanilla instead of chocolate...
Thomas F.
8/17/2025
Walked in on a Sunday night place was empty was so I was expecting fast service I was wrong. Three workers twittering their thumbs behind the counter. 10 minutes later a young woman asked what we...
Loretta L.
3/11/2025
I love Vanessa the cake decorator She goes out of her way to make my cakes special Sonny she deserves a raise :)
Jennifer R.
5/14/2025
Ordered a custom cake. They had no brownies and didn't include the caramel mid layer. This is the third time they've screwed up a custom order I had placed. The cakes are small and...
Owner verified
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Advertisement