Chester W.
9/18/2025
Neighbors that have been serving quality product for years. Had family visiting. NO DISAPPOINTED KIDS! pastor chet
Fair Shake
$
Closed
(20)
Advertisement
Photos
1509 Pennsylvania Ave
Pine City, NY 14871
The Fair Shake is a lively ice cream restaurant that offers a wide variety of flavors and sundaes. Guests can enjoy a fun atmosphere with additional attractions such as rides, photo boards, and a fish pond. This unique spot provides a great alternative to traditional hard ice cream with options like Dole with Pineapple.
Generated from the web
Reviews
4.520 reviews
Chavez M.
10/15/2025
Great ice cream friendly and courteous staff and it's ice cream! Right around the corner
Anna G.
6/28/2021
If you're ever Elmira-adjacent, make sure you give Fair Shake a fair shake. I'll see myself out. In all seriousness, the Fair Shake is a hidden gem. You'd have to know it was there, sitting in...
Ed L.
9/3/2020
I love this place. Hadn't been there in over 20 years and it is still awesome. Only place I can find my favorite ice cream which is vanilla with chunks of peanut butter. Prices are still amazing...
Bubba H.
10/16/2021
Love this place! Great small-town landmark: good ice cream, lots of flavors, hard ice cream and soft ice cream, fun stuff fir kids. We come here whenever we're visiting family in Elmira.
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement