Jason M.
6/21/2025
Great seafood and amazing portions of ice cream. This is a perfect example of never judge a book by its cover. A gem in the heart of Herkimer.
Fat Cats Herkimer
$$
Closed
(17)
Advertisement
Photos
200 King St
Herkimer, NY 13350
Fat Cats Herkimer is known for serving the best local fish fry and a variety of seafood dishes. With years of experience in providing fresh fish options, it has become a go-to spot for seafood lovers in the area. The restaurant is located in an old factory building, providing a unique atmosphere for diners.
In addition to its seafood offerings, Fat Cats is recognized for its soft serve ice cream. Customers can enjoy generously sized cones that have become a favorite among locals. The combination of fresh seafood and delightful ice cream makes Fat Cats a notable dining destination.
Generated from the web
Also at this address
Reviews
4.517 reviewsDave S.
9/28/2025
The food is cooked to perfection even though the place is mobbed with people. Prices are reasonable. We always get take out and never had a problem. The atmosphere and environment was that of a...
Emily S.
1/19/2025
Omg where do I start I have been getting fish from here since I was a child. My grandma used to work there and she always got me fish. It is so good if you're looking for a haddock dinner or a...
Steve M.
12/13/2022
When ever I'm in the Herkimer area I'm eating at Fat Cats. Fisherman's platter is a plentiful feast. I also get the fish fry dinner (not at the same time of course). And purchase seafood by the...
Ryan M.
8/9/2014
I've heard nothing but good reviews about this place for some time now. Large portion sizes and great prices. All I can say is wow! Delicious! Prices are very very fair and the food was...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Advertisement