Lena N.
12/2/2025
Very good pizza if you're in the LIC/Queens neighborhood. Easy and quick service pizza. Came out exactly what I expected NY pizza to be like. Thin, crispy, right amount of chewiness, perfect...
Goodfellas Pizzeria of LIC
$
Closed
(104)
Advertisement
Photos
2519 40th Ave
Long Island City, NY 11101
The Good Fellas Pizzeria of LIC is a popular dining destination located in Long Island City, New York, offering a variety of delicious pizza options to satisfy cravings for a quick and hearty meal. This establishment caters to both lunch and dinner needs, making it a go-to place for local residents and visitors alike.
With its convenient location and commitment to quality, Good Fellas Pizzeria invites patrons to indulge in their tasty offerings and experience the vibrant culinary scene in Long Island City. Whether for a casual meal or a late-night snack, this pizzeria aims to please all pizza lovers in the area.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.5(104)
Stephane V.
1/13/2026
Typical cardboard American pizza dough .. not good Canned sauce, i mean its a dollar pizza style pizza.. For people that are used to that... Its ok...
Vincent F.
12/30/2025
3.5 stars We got dinner from here. We ordered the pepperoni pizza and 1 chicken Parmesan pizza. Order was done within 20 minutes. Food was solid. Average pie can't go wrong with it. Not bad for...
Michael R.
10/31/2024
Stuck in Long Island City for another day, and jonesing for a slice of New York Pizza, I walked down the street and there was Goodfellas. Okay it's a hack name. as I grew up down the block from...
Angelina G.
10/18/2025
oh god don't go... it was a deep dish pizza with basically no sauce no cheese green pepper and onion and 5 pieces of mushroom. the entire thing tastes like old bad oil like the oven is super dirty...
See a problem?
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement