Ashley B.
12/6/2025
I work near by---this place is my go-to for lunch. Cashier is on point with my order every time--even remembers my name. Calzones are perfect, cold roast beef sub is the best around.
Jay's Pizza
Open
(17)
Advertisement
Photos
1169 State Route 29
Greenwich, NY 12834
Jay's Pizza in Greenwich, NY is a local eatery that specializes in a variety of delicious cuisines including pizza, calzones, subs, and wings.
Conveniently located near the Batten Kill River, Jay's Pizza offers online ordering for carryout or delivery, making it a go-to spot for satisfying cravings in the area.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.517 reviews
Curtis C.
11/24/2025
I ordered home delivery. I was disappointed that their Caesar Salad was made with Iceberg Lettuce. Caesar Salad is Always made with Romaine Lettuce. Cleverly, their menu does not specify the...
K D.
11/3/2025
This is one of my favorite pizza spots in the Greenwich area! I order delivery often, and they're always on time and friendly. I love that they offer vegan-friendly pizza options for my friends,...
Patti S.
11/23/2025
Had Jay's for the first time last night, it won't be the last. I'm from Long Island, and the pizza was the closest I've come to Calda in Hicksville, or Raimo's in Plainview. Thin crust, when you...
Thomas B.
9/8/2025
I called in my order...it was ready on time (30min...at peak dinner hour!) Greeted when I walked in...Pizza was great! I devoured it! I will recommend them to everyone...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.
Advertisement