Thomas C.
9/15/2025
Look for the brightly colored sign featuring the Puerto Rican flag or else you might miss Mamia's Island, an authentic family-operated Puerto Rican restaurant opened by owners Neymaris Sierra and...
Mamia’s Island
Closed
(33)
Advertisement
Photos
1808 State Route 104
Ontario, NY 14519
Mamia's Island in Ontario NY offers a delightful dining experience with a focus on fresh island-inspired cuisine. Guests can enjoy a vibrant atmosphere complemented by a diverse menu featuring seafood tropical flavors and local ingredients. The welcoming staff and cozy setting make it an ideal spot for families and friends to unwind and savor delicious meals together.
Generated from this place's information
Also at this address
Reviews
4.533 reviews
Timo R.
2/6/2025
We stopped at Mamia's restaurant during our lunch break. It was my first time having authentic Puerto Rican food and it was incredible. Their meat selection has a lot of different options of...
Jeanette T.
12/13/2025
Food is reheated from two days before nothing is cooked fresh, She orders frozen food from goya distribution and fry's them . Oil never gets change. Empanadas are pressed without gloves on, it's...
Francesca T.
12/12/2025
Rochester is blessed with so much wonderful Puerto Rican food and Mamia's Island is definitely high on my list of faves! Stopped by for lunch today for the first time, got a small order of rice...
Mary M.
11/8/2025
In the past the food was good and so was the service. Today, 11/8/25 my husband called to see how late they were open and the girl that answered the phone was incredibly rude. Heard her complain...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement