Robin M.
11/2/2025
Best seafood on Fire Island....amazing staff and bartenders. Family owned and operated since 1974. Amazing Dock with views of the great south bay.
Matthew's Seafood House
$$$
Open
(95)
Advertisement
Photos
935 Bay Walk
Ocean Beach, NY 11770
Matthew's Seafood House, located in Ocean Beach, NY, is a beloved seasonal dining destination that has been serving fresh seafood for nearly five decades. Closed for the season, the restaurant looks forward to welcoming guests back in 2024 for its milestone 50th season.
With a design by Spartan Impressions, Inc., Matthew's Seafood House offers a charming and inviting atmosphere for patrons to enjoy delicious seafood dishes in a beachside setting. Stay tuned for the reopening in 2024 to experience the culinary delights and seaside ambiance that have made Matthew's a local favorite for generations.
Generated from the website
Reviews
3.095 reviews
Nancy W.
9/6/2025
We love Matthew's! The view is amazing and the food is awesome. We have been going to Fire Island with our friends for the past 5 years, and even though there are 8 of us, the restaurants and...
Lina F.
8/29/2024
Amazing, friendly staff! Super family friendly and affordable lobster (like reasonably priced comparable to MacGuire's $60 for 1.5 which is nuts). They have a kids menu as well. The kids even...
Richard C.
9/7/2025
Love the vibe here. Food is good, drinks are stiff, the bartenders are excellent. I've been coming here for decades, and it continues to be a great experience.
Santino S.
7/28/2025
Food was bad, services ok, drinks were awful, I am not going back in there, very pricey not worth it
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement