Joel S.
11/11/2025
Swung by this cute shop in the company of a long time resident. The staff were nice. There was a big assortment of pot pies along with a number of pie adjacent offerings. I tried a single serve...
NoFo Pot Pies Country Market
Closed
(5)
Advertisement
Photos
11160 Main Rd
Mattituck, NY 11952
NoFo Pot Pies Country Market in Mattituck, NY, offers a delightful selection of homemade pot pies crafted from fresh, locally sourced ingredients. This charming market provides a cozy atmosphere where customers can enjoy high-quality, hearty meals perfect for any occasion.
In addition to their signature pot pies, the market features a variety of other delicious offerings, ensuring a satisfying experience for all visitors. The commitment to quality and community makes NoFo Pot Pies a beloved destination for both locals and travelers alike.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.05 reviews
Lauren L.
5/27/2025
Very cool little market with everything you need for a day out east, a picnic or picking up lunch or dinner to make things a bit easier. It gave very farm house-ish vibes with so much to look at...
Ticketytwo T.
10/23/2025
Everytime I visit my friend in the hamptons I have to come to this Mattituck location. They have the best bolognese sauce and split pea soup, soda bread. Lots of goodies. The sales lady is very...
Dave R.
7/18/2024
If you like pot pies, and happen to be on the North Fork of Eastern Long Island, stop in. That was us, on our way to the Cross Sound Ferry for the trip home to Massachusetts after visiting family...
NV R.
5/6/2025
Tiny store, sadly they cheat the elderly. When I inquired regarding the incorrect change, the clerk shrugged and said nothing. Did not care or apologize. We had made a large order for a party. The...
See a problem?
Advertisement