Esther G.
7/17/2025
Good drinks and food, and great vibes in the morning. There are the people posted up with their laptops, babies being passed around and people coming in and out. The chai is very good, and the...
Picky Barista
$
Closed
(40)
Advertisement
Photos
245 W 72nd St
New York, NY 10023
Picky Barista is a family-owned coffee shop in New York City that offers a cozy and hip atmosphere with a European vibe. With a passion for coffee and over 10 years of experience in the hospitality industry, Picky Barista serves delicious espresso drinks, including their incredible iced latte, along with homemade pastries in an adorably decorated space.
They proudly use Stumptown Coffee Roasters, known for their strong and creamy coffee sourced directly from producers around the world, and their espresso shots come out with the perfect amount of crema. With a commitment to sustainability and outstanding hospitality, Picky Barista has become a go-to spot for coffee lovers looking for a unique and enjoyable experience.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
4.040 reviews
Erik B.
11/28/2025
This place is always hopping with a long line for coffee, home goods, and a neighborhood atmosphere. If you're in a rush, this is not a good spot to visit given their level of foot traffic. I...
Alisa J.
8/20/2025
Cute shop service was so so slow. The balkan coffee was ok. Super strong and interesting flavor. The feta cheese boureke took them forever to prepare. Tasted good though.
Sophia W.
10/2/2025
Cozy coffee shop with lots of seating, wifi, and a bathroom. The staff are attentive and fast. I had an oatmilk matcha latte, and it was very creamy.
Alan W.
5/20/2025
Sadly this coffee placed missed the mark for me. There were a lot of customers, so perhaps I'm out of step here. We all ordered coffees. They came in 2 sizes. I ordered a small & it was REALLY...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement