Craig M.
9/29/2025
Great service. Best Italian food around. Great pizza, granda pie's and the veal is the best I've had in years!
Pizza Italia NYC
$
Closed
(22)
Advertisement
Photos
3593 Bayview St
Seaford, NY 11783
Pizza Italia NYC is a local pizzeria situated in Seaford, NY, offering a variety of traditional and specialty pizzas.
With a focus on quality ingredients and fresh flavors, Pizza Italia NYC provides a casual dining experience for customers seeking classic Italian cuisine.
Generated from their business information
Also at this address
Reviews
4.522 reviews
Noah K.
11/11/2024
Just moved from Lido to Wantagh driving around looking for my new pizza joint. Stella's didn't cut it, nor did Wantagh pizza. Glad I found Pizza Italia. Apparently it's the home of the round...
Rj S.
11/9/2025
Ordered to go entire order was wrong and chicken wings were bright pink inside called to speak with manager expecting at the least an apology considering we spent $100 on food we threw out but...
Lizzie H.
2/5/2024
The pizza was so good we came back a day later but through Uber eats - hey it was late & freezing on a Sunday. Don't judge us But now I can confirm NOT ONLY does their food travel well but their...
Gregg T.
11/25/2023
Oh my... the sauce on our Grandma Pizza was amazing! The cheese also had a unique bite and finish leaving you wondering what's in there? While we didn't order extra sauce, our pie had plenty!...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement