Anthony M.
12/27/2025
I discovered Polly's because I was having lunch with a friend at Tanner Smiths during the holidays before seeing a show nearby, and since they had to close the restaurant early for a holiday...
Polly’s
$$$
Closed
(35)
Advertisement
Photos
204 W 55th St
New York, NY 10019
Polly's is a cozy neighborhood cafe in the heart of New York City, offering a variety of freshly brewed coffee and delicious baked goods. The cafe provides a welcoming atmosphere for customers to relax and enjoy their favorite beverages.
In addition to coffee and pastries, Polly's also serves light breakfast and lunch options, perfect for a quick bite or a casual meal. With friendly staff and a laid-back vibe, Polly's is a popular spot for locals and visitors alike to unwind and recharge.
Generated from their business information
Also at this address
Reviews
4.5(35)
Steve C.
12/9/2025
Very cool spot beneath Tanner Smith's. We had drinks and dinner down here. My wife had a burger and enjoyed it, and I had the grilled veggie burger. Unfortunately, the veggie burger didn't have...
Julia K.
4/27/2025
Polly's / Tanner Smith's have some fantastic new items on the menu! The Quesabirria tacos are crunchy on the outside with succulent and perfectly seasoned beef inside, and come with a delicious...
Darcy D.
1/14/2025
I love everything about Polly's! I hate a speakeasy that's just a boring bar. This actually FELT like a speakeasy. First, the decor is perfect. There is art everywhere. The lighting is perfect....
Lauren M.
1/24/2025
Located below Tanner Smith's, Polly's is a classy speakeasy. The decor was stunning! I love the theme of strong women and learning about the history of Polly Adler. The teapot cocktail special...
See a problem?
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement