Toni B.
10/16/2025
We were in town for a music festival and we're lucky enough to spend some time in Sherman's both nights. Laura,, the bartender, and her daughter were amazing. They were not just friendly, but made...
Sherman's Tavern
$$
Closed
(20)
Advertisement
Photos
50 Pioneer St
Cooperstown, NY 13326
By day Sherman's Tavern is a laid back, easy going atmosphere perfect for either grabbing a quick drink and a bite while seeing the sights, or hanging out w/ friends and watching the games on our array of flat screens. By night we're a lively and happening night scene with pool league on Tue, Karaoke Wed, and always a busy weekend crowd. Great place for visitors and locals to mesh.
Also at this address
Reviews
3.520 reviewsNicole T.
10/25/2025
Staff is rude. If you're not a local, don't bother; they're not welcoming to tourists.
Dave F.
1/14/2023
Great, hometown bar. Warm, welcome staff. I'd recommend stopping in for a pint when in Cooperstown.
JP P.
8/30/2017
This is a great historic building in Cooperstown! We had the best wings make sure you get hot if you want some spice the medium was like mild. The pulled pork fries is pretty damn good! Try out...
Michael C.
4/30/2011
3.5 stars really. Sherman's one of the two bars in Cooperstown. No offense to Kristy, but it's not really fair to judge a bar in a small town on its Thursday night scene. Sherman's is best on...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement