Troy S.
12/4/2025
I lived in Carthage a long time ago. I was at the original location across the street that burned down over 20 years ago. This place was still pretty good. Attentive service. I was alone and I was...
Stefano's Pizzeria & Restaurant
$
Open
(86)
Advertisement
Photos
258 State St
Carthage, NY 13619
Stefano's Pizzeria & Restaurant, located in Carthage, NY, prides itself on offering a taste of Italy with a commitment to quality and freshness. All menu items are prepared to order from scratch, ensuring that customers enjoy the best seasonal ingredients available.
The restaurant provides options for dine-in, takeout, and delivery, with a focus on efficient service and customer satisfaction. Stefano's is also dedicated to fostering a motivated workforce, offering competitive pay and benefits for long-term employees.
Generated from the website
Reviews
3.586 reviewsJonathan W.
12/1/2025
A staple of Carthage, NY. The food is amazing and service is great. Can't go wrong with a pizza, wings and garlic knots. Hands down one of my favorite pizzas in New York. If you're looking for an...
Jelly W.
6/12/2025
The service itself was kind of pushy and the people working have a hard time following what the customer wants who orders a 8 sliced pizza with 7 of them pepperoni and the 1 slice cheese I mean...
Matt P.
6/30/2025
The pizza was very good as usual. Got a small cheese. Also got the calamari and while taste was mostly fine , it was some slightly over cooked . BIGGEST problem was they were not very warm or hot...
Lori N.
5/17/2025
Full menu of authentic Italian foods plus sandwiches, wings and more! Great service, plenty of seating and a separate room for parties and large groups.
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement