Tracy F.
11/26/2025
Had a nice lunch at The Tavern at the Colgate Inn. We ate the corn chowder soup and Caesar salad. The soup is creamy and made from local sweet corn with potatoes and bacon. It is hearty and...
The Tavern
$
Closed
(25)
Advertisement
Photos
1 Payne St
Hamilton, NY 13346
A Hamilton favorite, The Tavern is the ideal spot to grab a drink at the bar, enjoy a meal around a table in front of the fireplace, or relax on the patio for happy hour. Located inside the Colgate Inn, The Tavern serves farm to tavern cuisine for breakfast, lunch, and dinner daily.
Also at this address
Reviews
4.025 reviews
Danielle V.
8/12/2025
Overall some great things and some okay things: They have a large outdoor seating which is nice. I got the steak and it was cooked very well. The bread was good. My dirty martini was...
Alex S.
7/18/2025
please close your eyes and recall the most disgusting food and service you have ever experienced in your life. Well... The Tavern is worse.
Anthony H.
6/6/2022
With great outdoor seating at the Colgate inn, the Tavern is great for lunch or dinner, or even just grabbing a beer at the bar. The burger and fish came out quickly and the service from the staff...
Herb K.
2/28/2024
When not familiar with food establishments in a town, I always seek a place with a 4+ rating in Yelp, and have never been disappointed! That includes this place! Oh my! The soup of the day for...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Advertisement