Cori B.
11/16/2025
Timothy's pizza is great! We have been ordering from them almost every day when we need lunch for the contractors doing work on our house and they deliver the food on time while prepared and...
Timothy's Pizzeria
$
Open
(40)
Advertisement
Photos
10 Little Neck Rd Ste B
Centerport, NY 11721
Timothy's Pizzeria has been a staple of the Centerport community for over 30 years, known for its exceptional quality pizza and Italian specialties. Owned and operated by Mike Giuliani, who has diligently honed his craft since his teenage years, the pizzeria offers a diverse menu featuring traditional Neapolitan pies, Chicago Deep-Dish, Sicilian, and Gluten-Free options, alongside specialty slices and a variety of other delicious offerings.
With a commitment to freshness and quality, all ingredients are prepared in small batches daily, ensuring top-notch culinary experiences. In addition to pizza, Timothy's Pizzeria provides catering options for larger events and has been recognized by local publications for its outstanding food, including the best garlic knots on Long Island.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.540 reviews
Joe H.
4/22/2025
I saw a lot of good reviews from locals so we tried it out passing thru. Inside is simple pizza place. It was very warm inside almost to the point of eating was uncomfortable. I'm not sure why...
Jane W.
11/11/2025
We live in the neighborhood, but haven't been to Timothy's in years. Our recent visit has persuaded us that this should be our go-to pizza. The Sicilian is especially good.
Teresa K.
11/17/2024
Everything is yummy here! For me the lasagna is terrific My husband always love his meatball parm hero! Highly recommended as the best pizza around!
Pat L.
6/13/2025
Excellent cheese pizza !!! Plenty of shops nearer my area, but I gladly travel for this pizza !! Thankx Mike for the great service !!
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement