Mandy L.
11/19/2025
While the building isn't the newest (and by that I mean it's old)... the esthetic, service, and amenities all make up for a wonderful experience. If you're in for a real, quaint yet fancy Ohio...
Carlisle Inn
(18)
Advertisement
Photos
1357 Old Route 39 NE
Sugarcreek, OH 44681
Check-in: 3 PM, Check-out: 11 AM
Featuring an indoor swimming pool with a retractable roof, Carlisle Inn is located in Sugarcreek, Ohio. The property serves complimentary daily breakfast. Guests can find an Amish-style restaurant adjacent to the inn. Each simply furnished room is equipped with air conditioning. All rooms include a flat-screen TV. Select rooms will feature a balcony or patio. Room service is available. Guests at the Sugarcreek Carlisle Inn can enjoy live performances at the on-site theater. There is also a fitness center, a gift store and children’s playground. Free WiFi access is available. Dutch Valley Restaurant is located on the property and serves authentic Amish Dishes. The on-site Dutch Valley Market sells local meats, cheeses and foods. Carlisle Inn is 2.1 mi from Alpine Hills Museum and 7.4 mi from Warther Museum.
Reviews
4.518 reviewsCharles S.
11/26/2025
I rated this hotel badly because I had a situation worth sharing. I booked a night for my wife and I to attend a show at the Ohio Star Theater. I mistakenly booked the wrong date - I booked...
Sarah W.
9/5/2023
We stayed here while we were in town for a wedding. We loved it! Everything felt so clean and homey. The beds were very comfortable, staff friendly, and the atmosphere of the whole place was...
Chris M.
12/14/2022
It has been ages since a hotel has surprised me... My son and I were in Canton for the Pro- Football Hall of Fame game and as fate would have it the Carlisle Inn at Sugarcreek was the closest...
Sharaun F.
6/16/2019
My visit at Carlisle Inn was a great experience. We were in town for a womens conference and our entire group was impressed. Check in was seamless. We were greeted by smiling staff and a serene...
See a problem?
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement