Jonathan M.
10/9/2025
When I moved from Philadelphia, Pizzeria NY was like a taste of home. Authentic NY-style thin-crust pizza. Pepperoni Pinwheels are a meal in themselves. True story - my step-daughter and her...
Pizzeria New York
$
Closed
(55)
Advertisement
Photos
7950 E Broad St
Reynoldsburg, OH 43004
Pizzeria New York brings authentic New York East Coast pizza to the Columbus area, with recipes dating back to 1969 from the Brooklyn Queens neighborhood.
Founded by a family from Queens, NY, Pizzeria New York offers a menu featuring New York style pizza, lunch and dinner entrees, salads, desserts, and more.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.055 reviewsJoe L.
11/25/2025
The pizza here is always wonderful and they're friendly. They need to remove the items from the Reynoldsburg menu that they no longer serve there.
John M.
5/19/2025
Very good subs, the pizza is awesome. I will definitely be ordering from here again in the future.
Brandon B.
5/7/2025
Food was great ! First pizza since moving to Ohio ! Was not disappointed ! Solid Italian sub as well.
Jared D.
8/15/2025
Honestly it's better than sextons. Great NY style pizza. I got pep and cheese. Service was quick and friendly. I would even say I like it Better than Brooklyn pizza in Powell. I'll definitely be...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement