Karl S.
12/6/2025
mission style burritos in york pa since 2004 pizzas are great but always end up getting a burrito california steak monster chorizo chipotle chicken fajita all exellent beers are good, no TVs,...
Mexitaly
$$
Closed
(285)
Advertisement
Photos
2440 E Market St
York, PA 17402
Mexitaly Is A Scratch Kitchen And Brewery. We Pride Ourselves In Providing Good Quality And Quantity At Fair Prices. Stop In For A Pint! COVID hours are now 11-9 everyday.
Also at this address
Reviews
4.0(285)
Craig D.
7/28/2025
I used to be a regular customer at Mexitialy, since the beginning. The food is not the problem, it's always great! But, now it has gotten so expensive to eat there I rarely go anymore. I haven't...
Jarrod B.
12/3/2025
This place is SOOOO good! Was a favorite when I used to live in the area. Came back on vacation and did NOT disappoint! Was immediately seated, staff was attentive and friendly. Atmosphere is...
Mary E.
3/1/2025
For all the years I have lived in York, HOW have I never been to Mexitaly before?? I guess I was worried it would be an incongruous mixture of the two cuisines- but that is far from the...
William R.
1/19/2026
Brilliant food. The owner Greg is a great guy and his food is the best of both worlds!!
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.
Advertisement