Michelle S.
6/22/2025
I am absolutely thrilled with the BLT on a cheddar bagel that I get once a week. So very good!
The Bagel & I
$
Closed
(73)
Advertisement
Photos
20584 Timberlake Rd
Lynchburg, VA 24502
The Bagel & I, located in Lynchburg, Virginia, offers a genuine New York bagel experience crafted by owners Andrew and Kim Mather. Their commitment to quality is evident as bagels are made fresh daily, allowing customers to witness the baking process from start to finish.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
4.073 reviews
Heather B.
4/10/2025
Friendly and quick service, delicious bagel lunch with our grandchildren. They got chewy blueberry bagels and a smoothie. The adults had so many choices. The Wynhurst (chicken salad ) was...
Zachary T.
10/12/2025
8/10 times I go here they get my order wrong. Food tastes good and is in a convenient location. But consistently getting home and finding that they didn't put cream cheese on a bagel or...
Rachel B.
11/24/2024
UPDATED: I had a great experience with the Bagel & I during a catered event (probably one of the best bagels I've ever had), but when I went to their location in Lynchburg, I was disappointed. I...
Debbie J.
8/23/2025
Visiting Lynchburg and was excited to see a NY style bagel shop. Very disappointed with my cinnamon raisin bagel! Dry and no flavor whatsoever! The plain cream cheese was pretty lacking as well....
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Advertisement