Julie O.
11/23/2025
We stopped at Horse & Plow after the Winter Market at the American Club. It was pretty crowded as the annual market draws quite a crowd, but after looking around, I spotted one seat at the bar and...
Horse & Plow
$$
Open
(231)
Advertisement
Photos
419 Highland Dr
Kohler, WI 53044
This casual historic tavern was once the taproom for Kohler Co. workers who lived at The American Club®. Abundant booths convey a cozy atmosphere, while the tabletops, made from the original American Club bowling alley, perpetuate the historic tradition of Kohler Co. An expansive bar accommodates guests beyond the restaurant area, and a lower-level lounge features cozy furniture, televisions and fireplace. Enjoy American classics, such as burgers and fish ‘n’ chips, as well as fresh, innovative selections, such as our Midwest chicken salad and grilled salmon. With an exceptional selection of American microbrews and premium European beers, The Horse & Plow is a great place to meet for lunch or an after-dinner drink.
Reviews
3.5231 reviews
Dave M.
5/15/2025
I had been here years ago (pre-Yelp) and it was memorable enough for me to return 20 years later. I was worried based on some recent reviews. Don't listen to the whiners. Service was great...
Danielle P.
11/17/2024
We had a great experience at this restaurant! We stayed at the American Club last weekend and tried to experience at least one item from each of the restaurants in their collection. We were told...
Erik F.
10/15/2024
Friendly, professional service from our bartender Amira (then Andy) from my former "hometown establishment". Food items worthy. The Garden Salad was more a heap of greenery w smidges of...
Johanna H.
8/7/2025
Staff was a bit wonky the night we went. At first they said our table was ready but after 10 minutes and still not being seated they said they made a mistake and couldn't seat us right away (turns...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement