Ashley C.
7/4/2022
My new favorite restaurant in Star Valley! Had the white cream pizza, philly cheese steak sandwich, and carrot cake. The pizza crust was delish, and I don't normally love the crust. Best food I...
Tootsie's
Permanently closed
(64)
Advertisement
Photos
130 US-89
Thayne, WY 83127
History
*Summer 2021* New owners: Carly and Tye! *As of Sunday Sept 13, no more breakfast* We had an awesome 8 years of breakfast. We are sorry to see it go. We've been serving up authentic, third generation Italian recipes since 2001. The original New York recipes made their way to Wyoming and into the loving hands of Ross, Jan, and Ivy. Together with their terrific staff they spend every day making the best darned pizza this side of Manhattan.
Specialties
We've brought the signature flavors of New York all the way to you, Thayne -- from hand-tossed pizza to traditional pastas to subs on house-baked bread. We've also put our own spin on the classic New York diner menu with hearty country breakfasts to start your day off right. Everything is made from scratch because we know that's what it takes to serve you the very best. You'll savor every bite surrounded by a warm welcome and a friendly crowd.
Also at this address
Reviews
4.064 reviews
Shannon B.
8/8/2023
It's really too bad we had to come on their closing night because they had hardly any food left! They were out of almost everything, including some drinks, straws, all salads and most other...
Jared M.
12/16/2022
We have ordered takeout pizzas a few times now and they have been really good. Even after a 20 min ride home. Can't wait to try a few other things. The staff is always great and we never have to wait.
Anne C.
11/22/2022
Had lunch here today with my husband and one and a half year old grandson and it was excellent. My husband's BBQ brisket sandwich was the winner but my meatball sub was excellent as well. Very...
Aaron T.
1/3/2023
We love Tootsie's. We always go when we visit Thayne. They make great pizza and food. Service can get a little bit slow if it is busy but we don't mind. Well worth the wait
See a problem?
You might also like
Advertisement